Types of Auction and the characteristics
v Ascending-bid
auction (English Auction)
• Real
time interactive auction
• Bidders
present physically or electronically
• Seller
gradually increases price- bidders drop out until one bidder remain to win the
auction.
v Descending-bid
auction (Dutch Auction)
• Real
time interactive auction
• Bidders
present physically or electronically
• Seller
gradually decreases price from high value.
• The
first bidder, who accepts the current price, wins the bid.
• These
auctions are called Dutch auctions because flowers have long been sold in the
Netherlands using this procedure
v First
price sealed bid
• Offline
auction
• Bidders
submit sealed bid to the seller
• Seller
opens all the bids together.
• The
highest bidder wins the bid and the object.
v Second
price sealed bid (Vickrey Auction)
• Offline
auction
• Bidders
submit sealed bid to the seller
• Seller
opens all the bid together.
• The
highest bidder wins the bid and the object and pays the value of second highest
bidder.
v Multi-Unit
Auction – Dutch
• Starts
with low price and increase the price till supplier willing to provide one unit
of the goods or service.
• Price
raised slowly until suppliers have committed to all unit desired by buyer
• Each
unit is supplied with different price.
v Multi-unit
Auction – English Auction
• Starts
with high price and bidders announce the unit they are willing to supply.
• If
the quantity that supplier willing to supply is more than required by buyer,
the buyer reduces the price until the quantity matches the buyer’s requirement.
• All
suppliers get to supply at this price.
• This
auction is referred as Uniform-price auction
Factors
influence performance of a bid
• Supplier’s
cost structure – interdependent and correlated.
• In
similar market and similar processes, the interdependence and correlation is
higher
• If
the supplier is symmetric with the costs that are interdependent and
correlated, English auction brings lowest price for the buying firm.
• If
the structure is asymmetric, then second-price auction may do better than
English auction
Best
practices
• Buyer
must reveal all the information of the supply Chain task
• By
not revealing all the information, suppliers shade the bids to guard against
Winner’s curse
• Clear
idea of buyer’s own value, supplier’s value
• Divide
the bargain surplus in proportion to contribution of each party.
Comments
Post a Comment